Free bookkeeping for Clover clients

BookKeeping IncludedSchedule an Appointment
Blog · Card processing

The loyalty tax: why your card processing fees keep creeping up

Processing fees creep up because most businesses are signed up with a reseller, not the processor itself, and many resellers raise rates when the card networks update their pricing every April and October. Here's how the loyalty tax works and how to spot it.

Want to know a secret? Your credit card processor probably isn't your actual credit card processor.

There are only a small handful of real payment processors in the entire country. Everyone else, and there are thousands of them, is a reseller, a sales channel, or a bank selling that service under their own name. That's who most small businesses are actually signed up with.

How the loyalty tax works

Every April and October, the card networks update their pricing, and a lot of those resellers use the same dates to quietly raise your rates too. No phone call, no email. Just a line of gibberish in the notes of a statement you never look at. Little by little, your rate drifts from 2% to 3% to 4% and beyond.

We saw exactly this recently while working with a CAS manager at an accounting firm in New England. Most of the firm's clients are restaurants with one to three locations, and every one of them runs a POS of some kind. The firm had noticed fees that started around 2% creeping as high as 5% over the years, but they didn't have a solution for it.

We call that the loyalty tax. You stayed loyal, and they raised your taxes.

A 10-second statement review

That's where our head of payments comes in. He's spent nearly 20 years in this industry, and he's seen every trick in the book: smoke and mirrors, straight-up lying, the great deal up front that slowly turns into a bad one. He's seen statements that are impossible to read, and processors that go out of business and sell their book of merchants to someone who then raises everyone's rates.

Hand him your merchant statement, and within 10 seconds he'll know what you're really paying, where the extra fees were added, and whether it's a fair deal.

So that's how every conversation at BookKeeping Included starts. We take a real look at how you run your business, how you keep your books, and what kind of deal you're already getting on processing.

Two bills, one fix

Here's the thing: most small businesses are paying two separate parties. There's a merchant processor who keeps raising their rates, and a bookkeeper who's disconnected from how the business actually runs. We started BookKeeping Included to close that gap and bring both charges down to one fee.

We call it reducing the tech stack.

Common questions

Why do my processing fees keep going up?

Many resellers raise rates when the card networks update their pricing each April and October, often with nothing more than a note on the statement. Over time, a rate that started near 2% can drift past 3%.

How do I find out what I'm really paying?

Divide your total monthly processing fees by your total card sales for the same month. That's your effective rate, and our effective rate calculator does the math for you.

Is my processor the company on my statement?

Often not. Most small businesses sign up with a reseller or a bank that sells a large processor's service under its own name.

Related: Card processing fees explained · Effective rate calculator · 20 years of payment processing in a 2-minute read

Take payments on Clover? Your bookkeeping can be included.

Book a 30-minute discovery call and we will see if you are a fit. Eligibility and terms apply.

Book a Discovery Call
← All posts

No. 001